« On Writing Habits and Rethos | Main | On Pitfalls of the Environment Argument »

March 05, 2008

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451e92269e200e550ae01c58834

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference When is a Boycott a Boycott?:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Manya

Hello,

Can you explain why the Omaha Public Library ended up on your list? Thanks.

mary martin

Manya,

As I stated, I copied the list (and not even the whole thing) from an e-mail from the Sled Dog Action Coalition.

I will e-mail them and ask.

Eric Prescott

Whoa, what a coincidence. I have been writing a column on the subject of veganism not being a boycott for a couple of weeks now. Just put the finishing touches on it this morning, so this is an interesting (good) coincidence.

I am highly discouraged by that list you posted...

mary martin

Manya,

Here is the response I received:

The Omaha Public library is listed on the Sled Dog Action Coalition website as a race promoter. It paid Iditarod musher Matt Anderson to hype the race in a talk.

craig medred

are you truly naive enough to believe that margery glickman nonsense?

Terry Cumming

If this is indeed Craig Medred posting, funny for him as an Anchorage Daily News journalist (cowardly yellow journalists who support Idiotarod animal cruelty) to show his miserable presence on this site. Mr. Medred makes a good living as one of the prime Idiotarod/Alaskan sled dog industry propagandists. Shame on you, Mr. Medred. By the way, I as a fellow sled dog advocate, live in the Yukon, which is another hellhole for sled dogs, especially the poor dogs who suffer and die in the Yukon Quest (Yukon Disgrace). Extend my congratulations to your Idiotarod friends for killing their first dog this year - the first dog DURING the race that is. Many of these people are apparently 'prolific dog killers' the rest of the year. Thanks Margery for all the vital work you have done for the dogs. And thanks Mary!

Ray Boggs

It appears that Mrs. Margery Glickman Director of The Sled Dog Action Coalition has wrongly named Solatron Technologies Inc. a California corporation as a sponsor of the Iditarod race.

It appears that she has confused a domain name that is owned by Solatron Technologies Inc.(massachusettssolar.com) with Massachusetts Solar a Massachusetts company. Solatron Technologies, Inc. has no affiliation with Massachusetts Solar and has never been involved in any way with any iditarod race.

This has caused irreparable financial harm to Solatron Technologies, Inc. due to the degree and length of time that this false accusation has been disseminated.

In light of her negligence, Solatron Technologies Inc. and its attorneys are actively discussing legal action against Mrs. Glickman. Shame on Mrs. Glickman for not researching her information before causing damage to this company's good name.

Mary Martin

It appears that the company is a division of Solatron Technologies and the website lists Ray Bogg's as one of the company's founders. I was directed to this page:
http://64.233.167.104/search?q=cache:HuQfwJV6PkgJ:www.massachusettssolar.com/index.html+Massachusetts+Solar&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=5&gl=us&ie=UTF-8
("Our company's founder Mr. Ray Boggs with Mr. Chevy Chase and his wife at a recent Environmental Awards Dinner.")

Also, Ms. Glickman writes to companies before listing their names to give them the opportunity to correct any errors or end their involvement. She does this in the beginning of January and got no response.

Ray Boggs

The website massachucettessolar.com is a division of the company Solatron Technologies, Inc. There is no company that is a division of Solatron Technologies, Inc. Solatron Technologies Inc. is a sole entity. The company that sponsored the Ididorod has nothing to do with Solatron Technologies Inc. nor its website massachusettssolar.com. This is where Mrs. Glickman's mistake lies. Massachusetts Solar located in Massachusetts sponsored the Iditorod participant, massachusettssolar.com did not. Mrs. Glickman has been notified and has been given 72 hours to remove her false statement regarding Solatron Technologies Inc. and post a retraction and apology or she and her organization will face a libel lawsuit.

Mary Martin

I guess because of the similarities in names I'm confused. Luckily that's irrelevant, as it sounds like one way or another this episode will be over soon.

I hope this means you don't approve of the Iditarod.

Ray Boggs

As the President and CEO of Solatron Technologies, Inc. I will officially state here and now that I don't approve of the Iditarod nor any activity that abuses animals. This is why I am so upset over being falsely accused of supporting such an event. I am not interested in suing Mrs. Glickman, on the contrary I would like to see her continue her good work. But I must protect my company's good name and only request that she post the truth on her website. I am willing to accept the fact that she is confused about identifying the wrong company, but so far she has failed to reply to me, even though I have provided her with my email address, office phone, fax and cell phone number. My suggestion would be that she contacts the Iditarod organization and I am sure that they will confirm that Solatron Technologies, Inc. nor its website has ever sponsored any of their activities.

Mary Martin

Ray,
I'm so glad to hear that you don't approve of the Iditarod. I will put a correction into this post.

Ray Boggs

Thank you Mary

I called the Iditarod organization today and have asked them to provide me with a letter confirming that neither Solatron Technologies, Inc. nor Massachusettssolar.com has ever sponsored the Iditarod or any participant of the Iditarod. I will forward a copy to you as soon as I have received it. I will also attempt to contact Massachusetts Solar and will ask them to provide me with a letter stating that we have no association with their company. It appears that Margery Glickman's deadline has come and gone without her making any effort to correct the mistake on her website despite that fact that she finally did respond to my emails. Again thank you for allowing me to clear the record. Hopefully Margery will take the time to investigate and will learn for herself that I have been speaking the truth about this matter.

hannah

I am a dog musher from Anchorage Alaska, and I would like to clear up a few of the facts Margery Glickman stated in her comment.

First of all, the percentage of dogs that die in the Iditarod is not nearly as much as the percentage of household pets that die everyday due to starvation, being hit by cars, neglect, etc. Out of the 52 million pet dogs in the United States, 6.2 million die every year due to the above mentioned causes. Thats 12 percent. Out of the 1088 dogs that started the 2009 Iditarod, 6 died. Thats only 0.6 percent.

The injuries that occur in the Iditarod are no different or worse than the injuries in any other major race. In the 2008 Boston marathon, paramedics treated over 900 runners in their medical tents. The injuries included: 3 heart attacks, dehydration, hyponatremia, hypothermia, sprained muscles, tendonitis, contusions, stress fractures, and much more. Any sporting event will show the same statistics – many injuries occur.

In 2009, 505 dogs (out of 1088) didn’t finish the race. That’s 46%. Just because 46% of the dogs don’t finish the race, doesn’t mean that all 46% dropped out due to injury or other causes. Out of the 505 dogs that didn’t finish the race, 256 were on teams that dropped out of the race all together. A large majority of the dogs are taken out of the race because the musher is stopping for their best interest. If a dog team is not strong enough to complete the race, a musher will drop out for the sake of the dogs. The dog musher’s primary concern is the health and safety of their dog team.

Average lifespan of a pet dog is about 12 years. Average lifespan of a sled dog is 14 years. This is proof that sled dogs are very well cared for throughout their life, and receive the best treatment possible. This is what allows them to have such a long lifespan.

You mentioned the use of a whip. Not many mushers use whips, but for those who do, the whip never comes in physical contact with a dog. The use of the whip is to create a noise which the dogs are trained to respond to, just like if a musher were to yell a command at the dog. The dogs are not afraid of the noise – the cracking noise the whip makes can be compared to the whistle a person uses to train hunting dogs.

A musher is not allowed to pass through a checkpoint until the dogs are checked over by the veterinarians. All of the vets along the race course are so skilled and well-trained that they can spot injuries by watching the way a dog acts. There are multiple vets at each checkpoint, so when a dog team pulls in, it doesn’t take more than a few minutes for the vets to completely check over the entire team.

Most mushers chain their dogs using a 10 to 12 foot chain, which gives the dogs a 112 square foot area to run in. The average dorm room size (for 2 people) is 228 square feet. Thats 114 square feet per person. A 112 square foot area provides plenty of room for a dog to run around in. Dog yards are also chained in to prevent animals such as wolves and bears from getting in.

Colonel Tom Classen was quoted in the comment, however, I have no idea why his opinion is qualified on the subject of dog mushing. Sure, he is a long time Alaskan resident, but he has no history with dog mushing or any sled dogs at all. He is an air force Colonel, not a veterinarian.

Mushers do not race the Iditarod for “fortune.” The cost to raise, train, and care for a competitive 16-dog Iditarod team for just ONE year is between 150 and 200 THOUSAND dollars. The winning prize in 2009 was $69 thousand. Mushing is a very expensive sport, and no dog musher makes a profit off of it.

Please don’t judge dog mushing until you can actually see sled dogs at work and see how much they love to do what they do. The “Sled Dog Action Coalition” that Margery Glickman mentioned is based out of Miami, Florida. I’m not sure how anyone from Miami can have any real knowledge about dog mushing.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

My Photo

Google Search

  • only search Animal Person

My Other Accounts

Facebook Twitter

Twitter Updates

    follow me on Twitter