Skip to content

On Vegan Education, Marketing Problems and New Year’s Resolutions

Yesterday, Elaine commented that we have a "marketing problem," and that's where I was going with this first post of the new year. The Numerati deals with this problem in a chapter called Voters, which discusses the efficiency and effectiveness of reaching voters (and which groups should be targeted).

If you have limited time and money, you're not going to focus on the people who have already expressed support for your candidate, nor are you going to focus on those who have already expressed support for the other candidate. You'll focus on the people who are undecided. I think about vegan education and blogging. Because of the way I have blogged, and it was the only thing I could do because I am who I am, what I get most often is e-mail from people who have, like me, left welfare for animal rights. And that's great. I've made every mistake in the book and I can sympathize with just about any thought problem. Those people don't often comment, though, and I can only assume it's because Animal Person appears to be a site for vegan animal rights activists only. In other words, it looks like I'm preaching to the choir. And that's a problem. I convert people around me to veganism, but it doesn't happen that often through my blog. This tells me that my blog isn't effective, yet my real-life relationship advocacy is. Unless I alter my style on Animal Person, that won't change.

One thing that has changed is I used to inadvertently invite certain "tribes" to Animal Person to take them on. I'm thinking about hunters, Iditarod types and dog racers. These tribes have no reason to read my blog or comment other than to try to waste my time or use me as a source of entertainment, so attempting to have a serious discussion with them with the intent of converting them is not time-effective for me. At the same time, there's that tiny voice that says, "What if you could convince them to change their perspective and actions?" What are the odds of that, though?

Who do I want to reach, then? Who is it possible to reach? "Vegan sympathizers?" Probably. The TNR community, the greyhound rescue community, the anti-some-other-use/abuse community that has already demonstrated interest in changing the future of at least one other kind of sentient nonhuman.

Enviros, I find, are the most difficult to deal with and come up with the most absurd objections to veganism and animal rights, and most often my time isn't well spent with them, yet I do make a go of it.

Because the nature of Animal Person is transparency regarding my own journey, that includes the way I think about vegan education and how I might be able to improve upon what I am doing and how I do it.

In The Numerati, Baker relays a phone conversation with an old college roommate–"a PhD in computer science, who probably forgets every year or two more math than I ever learned" (215).

"'Ever hear of garbage in, garbage out?' . . . [M]athematicians model misunderstandings of the world, often using the data at hand instead of chasing down the hidden facts. He tells the story of a drunk looking for his keys on a dark night under a streetlight. He's looking for them under that lamp not necessarily because he dropped them there but because it's the only place with light" (215).

I want to look everywhere, not just the places with light, to try to figure out why some people will decide that animals are somebodies and killing somebodies when you don't have to isn't right. That's my #2 New Year's Resolution.

(Number One is exacting revenge for the five–FIVE–hours of ear-splitting "fireworks" that were nothing more than noise for the sake of it, right outside my door last night. For the first time in my life I actually uttered "I wish a plague of locusts should fall upon them.")

Simultaneously, I seek to know my audience. If I'm listening, I'll notice that each nonvegan I speak with has a hot button about animals that I might be able to use as my entree into a discussion, a book, a batch of cookies, a vegan meal, and a film that might cause them to decrease their consumption of animals. And I'll take that if I can get it.

6 Comments Post a comment
  1. Ian Smith #

    To carry the voting analogy further…there is something else that you may have accomplished with your blog that could be misconstrued as preaching to the choir and that is energizing your base. Even if most of your readers are abolitionist oriented vegans, by reading your blog, engaging the ideas, and keeping these concerns at the forefront of their minds, many individuals many gain a greater confidence in their beliefs, be able to articulate and defend them better, and be more motivated to reach out to others.

    Happy New Year!

    January 1, 2009
  2. Happy new year!

    THank you for linking to the soapbox 🙂

    Your post got me thinking about one of the books that shaped my life – a children's book. It's The Story of Ferdinand. The combination of animal cruelty with the pacifist message helped set me up for an AR perspective, I think. I read that book and sort of just knew. I have to wonder what would happen if that book were required reading in public schools.

    January 2, 2009
  3. Eileen #

    Ian made an excellent point. I don't often post here because others make such good comments that I rarely feel I can add much, but this has become one of my favourite blogs. Like you, Mary, I've been involved with welfarism (new and old) and in recent years I've had to break away from most of the organizations I once supported. I always enjoy hearing your perspective, and I can't tell you how much I admire your efforts to get a TNR program started in the face of so many obstacles. You're an inspiration!

    January 2, 2009
  4. Thanks, Ian and Eileen! I must admit to pondering quitting the blogging business. I think what I really need is to spend some energy increasing my small readership. But I'm a bit of a square peg, which I'm used to but I don't always know how to work to my advantage.

    Elaine: I've always said that if I had a child I'd homeschool, and precisely because I could choose the kinds of messages my child gets exposed to (while also making her aware of other messages out there). I can't imagine having to deal with a public school (especially here in Florida) and having to regularly undue what's been done.

    January 2, 2009
  5. "Those people don't often comment, though, and I can only assume it's because Animal Person appears to be a site for vegan animal rights activists only. In other words, it looks like I'm preaching to the choir. And that's a problem. I convert people around me to veganism, but it doesn't happen that often through my blog. This tells me that my blog isn't effective, yet my real-life relationship advocacy is."

    Mary – I've been reading for about six months, and rarely comment. Mostly because you say what I'm already thinking (and much more eloquently, at that!), and in the rare case you don't, other readers do.

    Anyway, perhaps it's not what you're aiming for, but in "preaching to the choir," I feel like your blog has another purpose."Energizing the base," as Ian said above, but also keeping us sane. I don't know many veg*ns in "the real world," and I've dropped many of my favorite liberal blogs as the speciesism has become intolerable. There are only a handful of blogs which I read regularly, and seriously, y'all are like an anchor!

    I also like that you don't seem to attract many trolls. I enjoy the AR blog at change.org, for example, and the readership includes some really thoughtful individuals. But I rarely read the comments thread – the speciesism and antagonism is just toxic.

    We all need our safe spaces, and Animal Person is one of mine. I hope that counts for something 🙂

    January 2, 2009
  6. kim #

    One example of a vegan blog that attracted lots of non vegans was Vegan Lunch Box. I don't know if it was because it focused on cooking, and kids, but her formula created lots of crossover participation.

    I think it's natural that the majority of your readers will be involved in the issues you discuss. I don't know how to get around that – but I'm sure lots of people stumble upon your blog that don't announce themselves. Do you track numbers? If your blog was entitled "How to Become Vegan" or something, and that was the focus, you would probably get more non vegans.

    I know I would miss your informative and thought-provoking posts, but I also understand the arguments against continuing – and the reality of plain ole burnout. I'm going to attempt to blog more this year, but I'm still not convinced the medium is for me, or if it's the best use of my time.

    January 2, 2009

Leave a Reply

You may use basic HTML in your comments. Your email address will not be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS